cherrytree group llc logo

Cherrytree Group LLC Blog

RSS Grab the Cherrytree Group Real Estate Blog feed

Get e-mail notifications of new blog posts! Enter email address below.


Delivered by FeedBurner

 

Massachusetts Ballot Questions, Question 2 Explained

Joseph Coupal - Monday, November 08, 2010

By Warren Kirshenbaum

In the recent election, Question 2 on the Massachusetts ballot asked whether voters should “repeal the law allowing developers of projects that include low- or moderate-income housing to apply for a single comprehensive permit from a city or town’s zoning board” The law in question is M.G.L. Chapter 40B, which is an expedited permitting statute. Chapter 40B creates an expedited permitting procedure for those developers that include an affordable component to their development. Specifically, in order to receive a permit under 40B, 25% of the housing units to be built must be considered affordable housing. The towns in the Commonwealth that are subject to 40B are those towns whose affordable housing stock does not exceed 10% of their total housing inventory. 40B subjects the Zoning Board to a streamlined procedure greatly reducing the time and cost of the permitting procedure, and limiting the ability of the town to deny the permit.

On Tuesday, November 2nd, Massachusetts voters, in a decisive victory of 58% to 42% voted not to repeal 40B.

This trend in the voting patterns comports with conversations that I had with people, in which it seemed that there was a lot of non-information, and even misinformation on this issue, and as this movement to repeal 40B could resurface again, I am hoping to shed some light on the issue in this post.

The main underlying issue that I sensed is the NIMBY one. Not in My Back Yard is understandable, and is a concern about falling property values and the denigration of a neighborhood when some of the housing is affordable. Declining property values is indeed a fallout of affordable housing, as the financing options discussed below are very favorable to developers or affordable buyers and, therefore, their properties. These affordability factors lower the market value of a single family home, or a multifamily property, and, therefore, affect the comps of other sellers in the area. This effect is a micro-economic effect, and a relatively minor one at that, as lower comps would affect a financing appraisal in small part, and the market value of a sale with even less consequence. In any event, 40B historically has mostly been used for multi-family construction, and 95% of the projects permitted under 40B are multi-family apartment complexes or condos.

Practically speaking, if a condo development were built near your home, whether it was affordable or market-rate your property value and property enjoyment would decline, so this is not an affordable housing, or 40B issue, as much as it is a land-use or urban planning issue.

Secondly, people I spoke to understood 40B to be a financing statute, and assumed that it gave developers funding to pursue their affordable housing projects. 40B is an expedited permitting statute that allows an override of municipal zoning authority to promote affordable housing. It is not a financing statute. There are forms of financing that are available to developers of affordable housing, such as the Federal Low Income Housing Tax Credit, HUD insured mortgages, tax-exempt bonds, Community Block Grants, and other state and federal sources of funding, and developers use these sources of funding once they are permitted, whether pursuant to 40B or otherwise. 40B is not a preamble to these sources of financing.

While realizing that concern over retaining a leafy suburban lifestyle, or holding on to a paper appraisal of a home value may be important to some in the micro-economic sense, it is not a positive economic trend in the big picture that justifies the repeal of a statute such as 40B. Consider this: a community is more than just our home values; it is a collection of individuals, families, homes, stores, houses of worship, and so forth. While we are happy when we see a fire truck scooting off to tame a brush fire near our neighbor’s yard, we would be foolish to attempt to exclude the possibility that the first responders on the fire-truck also be given the opportunity to live among us in our community by creating affordable options here, and not force them to be relegated to living in a far-off town for affordability reasons.

It should also be pointed out since its enactment, 40B has been credited with spurring upwards of 80% of the new development in Massachusetts, and there are several new developments, as well as many ongoing ones that would not have been built, or will not now be completed were 40B to be repealed, or if it didn’t exist in the first place. This construction has created jobs, spending, and economic activity that we rely on for our stability, and, particularly in our economic malaise, we can little afford to repeal a statute that has created such substantial growth and employment.

The Citizens Housing and Planning Association (“CHAPA”), a prominent Massachusetts non-profit that plays a decisive role in encouraging the production and preservation of affordable housing claimed that this vote evidenced the largest victory margin of any ballot campaign. CHAPA claimed that, “over 1.2 million voters and 80% of cities and towns affirmed their support for protecting the affordable housing law for seniors and working families in urban, suburban, and rural communities all across the state.” While this is true, an analysis of the voting results shows that the larger urban centers voted strongly in favor of not repealing 40B, constituting the largest slice of the 16% victory margin, while the voting in many towns was closer than this 16% victory margin suggests. Many towns actually voted in favor of repeal. Cities and towns such as Worcester, Somerville, Quincy, Arlington, Boston, Brockton, Lawrence, New Bedford and Cambridge opposed repealing 40B in large numbers, and they were joined by the suburban bastions of Newton, Needham, Lexington, Brookline, and Milton, which all together carried the NO vote on this question. Significantly, however, there were also several towns that voted to repeal 40B, such as Abington, Amesbury, Billerica, Bridgewater, Sudbury, Stoughton, Wilmington, Westford, Chelmsford, Tewksbury, Walpole, and Canton.


Recent Posts


Tags

brownfields, CT business solar investment tax credit commercial tax credits new market tax credit renewable resources capital line funding business investment hydro power fuel cell initiatives gasoline market manipulation foreign capital remedy operation status asset stripping Brownfields programs energy production REIT financing solar installations Broad Medows Salt Marsh REITS tax credits on brownsfields Seattle landfill gas facility Federal Historic Rehabilitation Tax Credit outsourcing tenant representative tax advantaged development Massachusetts Ballot Questions, Question 2 Explained private equity, MA geothermal Brownfields Act, MA commercial building tax deductions commercial energy tax deductions informational technology real estate lawyer partial equity participation new markets investments new energy technologies small residential properties Chapter 40B vote results historic tax credit renewable energy facility real estate investment trusts private equity' midterm elections capital raising questions, MA Louisianna renewable energy jobs credits qualified energy conservation bonds business loans geothermal power SRECs new normal declining property values income tax credit Massachusetts Brownfields Tax Credits largest accidental marine oil spill residential real estate develop renewable energy systems Massachusetts brownfields tax credit new markets tax credits small business Commercial Real Estate Loan Amortization Periods build green infrastructure investment solar renewable energy credits restoration projects equity requirements distressed asset investment financial incentives to develop real estate in MA free up capital thayer morgan interivew distressed assets downturn affordable housing sustainable technology brownfields laws wind EB-5 Regional centers investing in surface lots green energy hydro energy production tax-excempt bonds Summertime Economy in Boston commercial real estate attorney real estate wind power technology news commercial real estate lawyer borrowing by small businesses Tax Credit Commonwealth Solar Rebate Program brownfields redevelopment, CT commercial real estate in MA biomass facilities business EPA brownfields grant money offshore wind invest Boston deepwater horizon oil spill capital requirements QECBs solar ITC RAO buy commercial real estate, MA capital finance urban redevelpment tax credit broker raising capital, MA capped landfills wind power american recovery and reinvestment act tax advantages solar power development NMTC real estate strategy commercial investments investing in apartments, MA wind farm development multitude of renewable resources investment tax credits solar power market rate housing tax credit, MA brownfields tax credit rownfields Act oil spill renewable energy projects economic development bill, MA buy real estate, MA real estate properties historic rehabilitation tax credit Warren Kirshenbaum green standards federal low income housing tax credit solar energy array projects cleantech cities real estate business asset wind subsidies distressed asset investment fund, ma commercial real estate low-income neighborhoods sale of a tax credit banking financing commercial tax credit commercial tax credits, Lowell heat and power solar energy investment into business hydro electric power construction monstrous oil spill solar energy markets developing real estate in MA energy tax credit commercial leases Kirshenbaum Real Estate invest in commercial real estate green energy projects BP Gas station owners tax credit programs, New Bedford CHAPA renewable energy tax break foreign investors credit for income producing properties MA Rhode Island commercial tax credits, MA Brownfields Tax Credits, MA low-income housing tax credits secure capital business capital thayer morgan large capital projects investments in solar energy commercial properties new markets motion picture tax credits solarize Massachusetts investing in commercial real estate private equity offerings private investments solar capacity tax credit to spur redevelopment Cape Cod American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 - Section 1603 40B credited with spurring upwards of 80% new development cleantech capitals tax credit consultant real estate investments REIT investments San Francisco tax incentives money lending new market tax credits invest in real estate recession gasoline price fixing solar installations equity low income housing tax credits private equity tax credit syndication community development financial institutions cost of producing renewable energy economic growth investing in real estate in MA biomass power commercial real estate investment community development entity new york pops Historic rehabilitation tax credits, MA solar energy development tax breaks Business Financing sale of renewable energy credits more control over financing costs negative environmental effect cleantech EB-5 Green Card Program value-added services deduction for energy efficient buildings transfer of tax credits LIHTC FERC small business loans real estate deals The Transactional Law Group - MA energy efficient tax deductions San Jose commercial tax credit attorney NYC tax credits renewable energy tax credits solar farms private sector investments solar energy properties tax credits to help economy renewable energy certificates commercial tax credits, New Bedford investors in renewable energy investing in apartment projects, MA energy companies brownfields tax credits preservation of historic buildings capital funding workforce development rehabilitation Brownfields Act, economically distressed areas, Massachusetts Brownfields Tax Credits, Massachusetts Contingency Plan, MGL Ch 21E, RAO, remedy operation status, renewable energy, sale of tax credits, tax advantaged development, tax credit syndication, tra non-renewable energy sources visas for imigrants fuel cells loaning money to consumers real estate projects commercial buildings brownfields tax credit, MA The Cherrytree Group Former Getty owners renewable energy industry examine tax credits expensive to produce Housing Development Incentive Program, MA LIHTC tax credits developing real estate, MA build a wind farm clean energy Transactional Law Group polluted sites tax credit, New Bedford venture capital solar facilities solar system wind tax credit commercial real estate investments real estate investment trusts, Boston solar pilot program massachusetts non-profit LIHTCs federal tax Credit economically distressed areas economics of environmental projects tax credit sydication Gulf Coast victimized Martha's Vineyard tax credits new housing developments federal government hedging transactions solar projects solar power initiative EB-5 economic slump brownfields REIT industry RECs wind energy credits federal tax credits alternative funding sources Massachusetts Contingency Plan brownfield redevelopment, CT the difference between tax credits and tax deductions historic building tax credit, New Bedford SREC real estate attorney NIMBY not in my back yard MGL Ch 21E historic preservation tax credit real estate attorney, ma tax credits for gateway cities, New Bedford development in Massachusetts solar investment tax traditional funding Chapter 40B explained debt-service private equity offerings, ma Quincy Broad Medows Salt Marsh list of brownfields sites tax planning strategies tax deductions methods of renewable energy production visas for buying homes alternate funding Austin energy tax credits clean technology sydicator of tax credits gas station loss of income Housing Development Incentive Program boycotting BP gas stations weak economy marine and hydrokinetic, solar capital borrow money community block grants renewable energy wholesale acquisitions investing in parking lots expiring tax credits commercial real estate owners community development federal energy regulatory commission biodiesel preservation of mills private sector investment RI building improvements renewable energy expensive to produce wind farm tax credit capitalism multi-family apartments american symphony orchestra real estate investment, Boston solar energy production BP oil spill sale of tax credits contractors, Boston, MA real estate, Boston Massachusetts state tax credits developers, Boston, MA renewable energy credits tax incentive deals investment objectives residential properties destructive oil spill tax incentives and credits Massachusetts tax credits trash facility brownfields redevelopment, MA new markets tax credit program obtaining capital environmental projects Brownfields sites brownfields, MA economy equity investments how REITs works independent gas station owners renewable energy incentives making money with commercial real estate 1603 Treasury Grant Quincy, MA global energy demand portability of tax credits tax deductions microturbines tax credit investments 1603 Grant Massachusetts historic and low income housing energy systems commercial tax credits, Fall River Brownfields credits real estate development new market foreign investment development of the renewable energy industry multi-family construction construction jobs solar investment tax credit monetizing your tax credits Kirshenbaum Law, Cherry Tree, LLC, Real Estate, MA renewable energy program HUD insured mortgages REITs, Boston investing in surface parking lots energy efficient property Chicago Cape Wind investing in commercial real estate, Boston non-bank resources for capital funding distressed asset investing multi-family housing, MA depressed and booming markets credit line funding sources of funding real estate lawyer, MA finance solar initiatives brownfields projects, MA devastating environmental damage office space Brownfields sites, MA tax credits to fix up historic buildings distressed asset sales renewable energy development Massachusetts gas station owners Plymouth, MA brownfields tax credit, CT cherrytree group llc private equity offerings venture development capital MA federal and state tax credits citizens housing and planning association invest in development projects permitting procedure wholesale energy Historic rehabilitation tax credits distressed asset investment fund laws of Brownfields

Archive

Disclaimer

This Blog is made available by the lawyer publisher for educational purposes only as well as to give you general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. By using this blog site you understand that there is no attorney client relationship between you and the Blog publisher. The Blog should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state.